Grace Under Fire: How to Respond to Criticism Without Burning Bridges
You put yourself out there, try something exhilarating, and then it happens. An email from someone you respect throws a wrench into your otherwise glowing experience. How do you respond? Sit tight; I’m about to share my journey through this very landscape.
My Unforgettable Encounter: John’s Unexpected Email
So, there I was, riding high on the applause of a stand-up comedy gig—200 people, laughter, a real hit. Just when I thought I could take a breath and enjoy the afterglow, an email notification on my phone caught my eye. It was from John, a friend and mentor who’d always been in my corner.
John wrote, “I’m disappointed, Preston. Why work so hard to build the image of a godly man, only to perform the same kind of comedy everyone else does?”
His words hit me like a freight train. I was ready to hit back, and boy, did my fingers itch to type out a defensive masterpiece. But then, I stopped myself.
Turning Points: How I Navigated the Criticism
The Pause: A Moment of Gravity. Right there, I had a choice: give into the gut reaction or let wisdom take the wheel. I chose the latter.
Asking the Unasked: I took a deep breath and typed, “What did you find offensive?” Sometimes, asking for specifics can defuse a situation more effectively than you’d think.
The Soft Answer: My Line of Defense. John replied, specifying that he turned it off during the “farting part.” Instead of being confrontational, I chose humor. “Ah. William Shakespeare and I have something in common, then; we both love a good fart joke.”
Reflection: Facing My Inner Jury. I pondered, “Did my stand-up align with my higher goals and values?” It’s the tough question we often sidestep, but it’s crucial for personal growth.
Preservation: Keeping the Door Open. It’s tempting to cut ties when criticism hits close to home. Instead, I opted for grace. “Thanks again for the note. All my best and take care.”
The Outcome: A Lesson Cloaked in Criticism. It could have been a battle of egos, but it ended as a valuable lesson and a preserved friendship. “You too. And keep in touch,” John replied. These simple words carried the weight of a meaningful, if challenging, exchange.
So, what will you do when that email, text, or comment hits you like a ton of bricks? Will you let defensiveness cloud your judgment? Or will you choose a path that might lead to growth, understanding, and perhaps even a deepened relationship?
The moment after you read a critical message can either be the countdown to an emotional detonation or the beginning of a wiser, more understanding you. Which will you choose?
Have you ever been in a similar situation? I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences. Share them below; your story might be the guidepost someone else needs today.
Want to discover how to become an exceptional leader? Visit my website, http://www.prestonpoore.com, today.
I'm an award-winning Fortune 500 executive with over 30 years of experience, including tenures at The Coca-Cola Company, The Hershey Company, and Ralston Purina. On top of that, I am a Numerica Corporation co-owner and board of directors member, published author, and a John Maxwell Team certified speaker, trainer, and executive coach.
My learnings and lessons are not drawn from the classroom of academic theory but from the crucible of marketplace trenches. I share my hard-earned experience with audiences to help them, their teams, and organizations become the best version of themselves.
Discover Your Life Purpose
Do you wake up each day dreading the idea of spending another day at work? If you’ve failed to discover and build your life around your life purpose, you might feel dissatisfied with your life. Flip the script! Get this special eBook, discover your purpose, and begin living a more fulfilling life today!